#62: Why Human Struggle Isn’t a Brain Disease

Episode 62 • November 19, 2026 • 00:26:07
#62: Why Human Struggle Isn’t a Brain Disease
The Dr. Zwig Show
#62: Why Human Struggle Isn’t a Brain Disease

Nov 19 2026 | 00:26:07

/

Show Notes

The concept of "mental illness" imitates the biomedical concept of a disease entity, yet psychiatric diagnoses aren't discovered through lab tests or biological research—they're created by committees debating and voting on fabricated checklists. 

In Episode 62, I break down how psychiatric diagnoses are constructed behind closed doors, and look closely at how sudden changes in the DSM triggered a massive wave of bipolar disorder diagnoses—right at the exact moment pharmaceutical companies rebranded antipsychotic drugs as "mood stabilizers." 

Your suffering isn't a defective brain mechanism. It's a meaningful human process of personal change and growth trying to come forth. 

This content is for informational and educational purposes only. For medical advice, or psychiatric/psychological diagnosis or treatment, please consult a licensed professional.

drzwig.com - instagram.com/drzwig - youtube.com/drzwig - facebook.com/drzwig

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Do you know the origin of the idea that distressing states of mind like depression, anxiety, delusions and so on are illnesses like medical diseases? For example, is it a scientific concept based on empirical studies, or is it just a general, common, subjective way to think about human problems? [00:00:21] Is the notion that mental distress is analogous to medical conditions like cancer, heart disease and diabetes a female feeling or an intuition? [00:00:32] Or is it science? [00:00:34] The answer may surprise you. [00:00:38] Now, today I've got a super juicy topic to dive into with you. [00:00:44] It's something I'm really passionate about because it affects so many of us in so many ways. [00:00:51] But before jumping in, I want to warn you this is not for the faint of heart. I've got my sword out and I'm going to cut through through to the center. If you're okay taking psychiatric medications, you may not want to watch this video and that's totally fine. [00:01:08] Also, never stop psych meds without doctor supervision and therapeutic support. [00:01:15] I'm going to identify and discuss a core problem in psychiatry and psychology. [00:01:21] In order to do so, I want to address two issues with critiquing mental health practice. The the first is obvious. It's a highly sensitive topic. The awful stigma around mental health issues has people on guard against being put down and marginalized, and rightfully so. Therefore, from the outset, let me say I'm a champion of the fact that every human being has a life process to deal with and problems are a natural part of it. In fact, we need problems. Without them, our potential would go to sleep. [00:01:57] However, we have to be careful not to misinterpret critiques of the system as indications of stigmatizing those of us who are suffering. To the contrary, the only way to make progress is to identify and challenge faulty methods. The second has to do with language. [00:02:15] Modern linguistics tells us that our words don't just reflect reality, they create it. [00:02:22] They do so by describing experiences from a particular viewpoint. [00:02:27] Mental health terminology creates the ways in which we view and respond to painful states of mind. Therefore, we have to be aware of the implications of the words we use. Terms like mental illness, disorder, diagnosis, and so on. These words denote specific viewpoints on people's problems, not the experience of pain and suffering itself. [00:02:54] In other words, asking whether mental distress is a disease questions the interpretation and labeling of these problems, not the reality of their existence. [00:03:05] I'm going to begin by telling you about me and the mad hatters. For 10 years, I lived in Zurich, Switzerland, where I worked as a psychologist in a psychiatric clinic. I also had a private practice. I worked One on one with some of the most extreme people in the population. [00:03:23] I also conducted and continue to do research on all types of mental distress. [00:03:29] So where did the idea that your problem is an illness come from? [00:03:34] Well, for millennia, humans attribute a deep mystery to physical ailments. [00:03:40] The idea that abnormal signs and symptoms could indicate a variety of underlying diseases was the conclusion arrived at only after a century of rigorous scientific research involving thousands of peer reviewed studies. No one just spontaneously thought to himself, I'll bet chest pain can be a sign of a heart attack or acid reflux, or a muscle or bone problem, or a lung condition or a stomach problem. [00:04:10] Each of these ailments contains its own highly specific parameters that help the doctor differentiate and diagnose the underlying disease. [00:04:20] In contrast, the notion that depression, anxiety, attention deficit and so on are illnesses didn't derive from scientific research, but rather from a desire to make psychology sound more like medicine instead of scientific evidence leading researchers to the conclusion that a terrible state of mind is a disease. The idea originated from the common, everyday lay assumption we make when we see someone who feels messed up or, or acts weird, or when we feel depressed or anxious and think there's something wrong here. [00:04:57] If it's painful or antisocial or irrational, it must be wrong. [00:05:02] We must be sick. But this is an instinctual interpretation without any grounding in fact or scientific evidence. [00:05:10] It's like how we experience our experience of the earth as being still, when in fact it's moving at about 1,000 miles an hour. [00:05:19] Everything about mental health practice, diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, and so on is built on this core false assumption. But there's never been a single scientific study providing evidence for it to make a medical diagnosis. A doctor uses research data to differentiate the many possible reasons for one's signs and symptoms, and arrives at a specific disease entity. [00:05:44] In contrast, there is no research demonstrating that mental or emotional pain can be differentiated into distinct psychological entities. There are no studies showing that a specific group of symptoms, underlying processes, can be clearly distinguished from all other symptoms and processes, or from no symptoms and processes. [00:06:08] Without research data to distinguish between underlying causes, we can't identify diseases. [00:06:16] Psychiatry and psychology's use of the word illness derives from the common lay meaning of the word, not the scientific meaning. Nevertheless, they label groups of symptoms in a way that makes them sound like diseases, even though there's no underlying research data. [00:06:35] A simple way to understand this is to look at how medicine did this exact same thing before the discovery of germs in the 1800s. [00:06:45] It classified symptoms into arbitrary clusters and Invented disease names for them without having any idea of what was causing them. The psych diagnostic manual called the dsm. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, which by the way contains no statistics, uses scientific sounding jargon, but it's a dictionary of symptoms with no objective measures associated with them. [00:07:13] A diagnosis of clinical depression is like a diagnosis of chest pain, A symptom without any underlying principles or processes. [00:07:24] Let me repeat that so it sinks in. A diagnosis of clinical depression is like a diagnosis of chest pain or headache. Chest pain and headache aren't diseases, they're symptoms. And they could indicate a wide range of underlying problems. But psychiatry and psychology give disease names to symptoms. [00:07:46] As soon as the public hears these words, they assume these diseases are on par with medical diseases. [00:07:52] And since there's an official nomenclature published in a professional manual, the DSM people think it must be based on science. [00:08:02] It's not. [00:08:03] The entire psych diagnostic system is based on pseudoscientific methods that give practitioners a certain degree of consistency and diagnosis, but offer no evidence of validity. [00:08:17] So why has the public bought into the fraudulent claim that a messed up mind or life indicates a disease? [00:08:25] Precisely because it appeals to our shared common sense feeling that abnormal or unusual behavior and experiences are wrong, that they're pathological and therefore should be treated as diseases. [00:08:38] But remember, the whole reason science exists is to transcend the limitations of common sense ways of perceiving the world. Without it, we'd still believe the sun goes around the earth, the earth is flat and infectious diseases are caused by general bad air without any idea about germs. So while it may make intuitive sense to think that depression, anxiety, phobias and so on are illnesses, that there's simply no science to back it up. [00:09:09] Furthermore, despite the way researchers, who are often paid by drug companies spin this in the media, there are no actual studies confirming the hypothesis that mental health problems are caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain. [00:09:25] Not one. [00:09:27] Despite psychiatry and the pharmaceutical industry's billion dollar ad campaigns aimed at selling the public on the chemical imbalance idea, causation has never been demonstrated. [00:09:41] In fact, massive meta studies have debunked the entire idea. [00:09:47] Then why does your antidepressant or anti anxiety drug relieve your distress? To an extent. [00:09:55] Allow me to explain. There are two models of drug action, the disease centered model and the drug centered model. In the disease model, drugs work by correcting an underlying abnormality. [00:10:10] Psychiatry borrows this idea from general medicine, where most drugs are understood to act in this way. Think of any drug you take for a medical Problem in the drug centered model. Medications are psychoactive substances which alter the way the brain functions. They don't normalize the body, but rather work by creating an abnormal or altered state. [00:10:36] In other words, they don't fix an imbalance, they create one by working on the brain to alter the perception of feelings, thoughts, emotions and behavior. [00:10:47] The more pleasant altered states they create may be preferred over the distressing ones inherent in pain, depression, anxiety, psychosis, and so on. [00:10:56] An example of this way of thinking about drugs is the idea that alcohol is useful for social anxiety disorder. The idea isn't that alcohol fixes a chemical imbalance or that it replaces an alcohol deficiency, but rather that the characteristics of alcohol intoxication include becoming socially less inhibited, which can be useful for someone who finds social situations difficult. [00:11:24] Another example is the effect of opiate painkillers like morphine. [00:11:29] These drugs have a disease centered action in that they have a direct effect on neurological fibers that conduct pain. But they also have a drug centered action by creating an altered state, typically characterized by emotional indifference and detachment. [00:11:46] So people who take opiates for pain often say they still have some pain, but they don't care about it as much. [00:11:53] Here's the deal. [00:11:55] The public has been misled by psychiatry and Big Pharma to believe that psych meds work on the disease centered model. They don't. Psych meds don't target or fix any type of chemical imbalance. They induce an altered state that simply masks symptoms. It's the exact same as taking street drugs without the legal issues. [00:12:22] Your problem isn't caused by a brain disorder. It's an expression of your inner story, and with the right tools, you can process and transform it. [00:12:33] That's what this podcast is all about and what I'm going to teach you now. Think about it. Identifying a brain disorder would require a medical exam, like some type of diagnostic scan. But this is not done in psychiatric diagnosis. [00:12:51] All diagnosis in psychiatry is done through a questionnaire. [00:12:55] The DSM uses language that's precise enough to sound scientific, but vague enough so that you can't really pin it down. [00:13:04] Adjectives like excessive, for example crying, sleep, weight, fluctuation, or repeatedly, for example going over thoughts or overly, for example reflective are used in place of hard science. [00:13:19] Who can say what excessive is excessive according to what or who? [00:13:24] The terms are anything but scientific. [00:13:29] Since there is no science foundation upon which the disorders are based. [00:13:33] Each new edition of the diagnostic manual freely changes and redefines the disease criteria. [00:13:41] In addition, the diagnoses use arbitrary time frames for Example, two weeks of feeling depressed as the threshold for receiving a diagnosis of clinical depression. [00:13:55] Now, I've always been curious as to what mysterious event happens on the 15th day. [00:14:01] On day 13 and 14, you're fine, you just kind of feel down. But Suddenly on day 15, you've got a mental illness. [00:14:10] Psychology wants to be seen as a respectable field on par with medicine. And psychiatry wants to be taken as seriously as the other medical specialties. And they both seek to accomplish this by borrowing medicine's concept of disease entities. [00:14:27] However, unlike in medicine, mental illnesses are not identified through research, but rather through consensus among a group of so called experts who feel that a certain cluster of symptoms belong together as one disease, even though they have no idea how or why and why they keep changing. Ponder this. A group of professionals sit around a conference table deciding what disease categories and names should be used to classify your problems. [00:15:01] The conclusions are arrived at according to what they think and feel, not according to any hard research data. [00:15:09] Then each disease name category gets an insurance code that has to be used by the therapist. If the therapist doesn't use one of these diagnostic labels and codes, she doesn't get paid. [00:15:21] Mental health diagnosis is an imitation of medical diagnosis, but without the science. [00:15:29] Imagine if medicine used a dictionary of symptoms that had no underlying research foundation and was created by a small, self proclaimed experts. [00:15:40] Now you think I'm being unscientific or unreasonable or reactive in all this? [00:15:45] Well, guess what? [00:15:47] Neuroscientist and psychiatrist Thomas Insel directed the National Institute of Mental Health, the largest mental health research funding organization in the world, until 2015. [00:15:58] He said the exact same thing about the newest diagnostic manual of the time. In fact, just two weeks before the manual was due to appear, the institute withdrew its support for it in a humiliating blow to the American Psychiatric Association. Insull said the agency would no longer fund research projects that rely exclusively on criteria from the dsm. He said the weakness of the manual is its lack of validity. [00:16:29] Unlike our definitions of heart disease, lymphoma or aids, the DSM diagnoses are based on a consensus about clusters of clinical symptoms, not on any objective laboratory measures. What I've discovered is that what people call mental illness is actually a meaningful and purposeful process that's trying to force the individual to change and grow. It's trying to wake you up to something new, a new way of thinking, feeling, perceiving, behaving, being a new consciousness. A really terrible state of mind I know takes the ground out from under you. [00:17:08] It disorients you, it makes you doubt everything in yourself. It makes you unable to function in the world. [00:17:15] It literally turns your life upside down. But it contains an underlying logic. It's trying to tear down the current system that is you in order to catalyze your transformation. Your messed up mind is your calling to greater things. And it's meant to be processed by, not just suppressed or managed. [00:17:38] Years of clinical work have taught me that every problem, no matter how crazy and severe, is logical, meaningful and purposeful. It contains information that's essential for your growth rather than being a disease to diagnose and treat. It's an expression of profound change desperately trying to happen. [00:18:00] In fact, the worse the problem, the stronger and more urgent the process needing to come to awareness. [00:18:08] Even people labeled schizophrenic or bipolar can completely transform their issue in life. I saw it many times at the psych clinic I worked at in Switzerland. [00:18:20] So this isn't just a theory I've come up with or a philosophical viewpoint I identify with. [00:18:29] It's a conclusion I arrived at after empirical observation and experience with thousands of clients. [00:18:37] The problem is that the mental health field has failed to develop its own model, relying instead on the medical model as a template. [00:18:47] Medicine views signs and symptoms as pathology to get rid of. [00:18:52] Now, if you think about it, this is an appropriate and effective paradigm for addressing a lot of physical ailments because it's grounded in quantitative science. You can measure what's going on and you can compare it to standards. [00:19:07] But when you try to apply this model to mental and emotional issues, you run into a major, major obstacle. Our states of mind are intangible, fluid experiences of meaning and are not a of matter amenable to the quantitative parameters used in medicine. [00:19:27] The result is a well meaning mental health profession that uses a completely non scientific classification system of diseases. [00:19:37] To the uneducated public, it looks, sounds and feels like real science, but it's not. Take for example, the common diagnosis of bipolar disorder. This diagnosis is associated with mood swings from deeply depressive to manic highs. The depressed phase includes symptoms such as low energy, low motivation and loss of interest in daily activities. While the manic episodes include symptoms such as high energy, reduced need for sleep and in some cases, loss of touch with reality. [00:20:14] In the US alone, there are 3 million cases diagnosed every year. [00:20:19] The conventional wisdom about this illness is that it lasts your whole lifetime, which means you'll always need medication, talk therapy and systems for managing your symptoms. [00:20:32] Now, if you examine these criteria a bit closer, you enter into murky waters, low energy and low motivation. How low what's the threshold? We're feeling low or tired becomes a disease. [00:20:47] Who and what determines this? [00:20:49] Similarly, high energy and reduced need for sleep. [00:20:55] How high can you go before you have the disease? There's simply no quantitative criteria. There's no threshold. Now, loss of touch with reality is a bit more of a complex notion that I'll hack into in the next episode, where I tell you a case example. But it's not what you've been made to think. [00:21:15] The idea of bipolar disorder is that some people have too much fluctuation in their high and low moods. But again, how much is too much? [00:21:25] And how do we know when someone has arrived at this level? [00:21:30] Even if there was a way to measure mood fluctuations, which there isn't, how would we know what level constitutes a disease? [00:21:39] And here's where it really goes off the rails. If these vague criteria are arrived at by consensus within a group of psychologists instead of by scientific research, wouldn't that mean the diagnostic elements could be manipulated to alter the frequency of this diagnosis? [00:21:58] Hmm. If there are no hard parameters to adhere to, couldn't these folks arbitrarily decide who's sick simply by changing the rules? [00:22:07] The answer is yes. [00:22:10] In the 1990s, the authors of the DSM arbitrarily decided to lower the threshold for the manic side of the bipolar equation. They said, you don't need to go crazy ecstatic high. You just need to get into a nice state of mind where you feel really good. [00:22:26] Guess what happened? [00:22:28] Diagnoses skyrocketed. [00:22:32] Everyone and his sister suddenly had bipolar disorder. Because you no longer need to flip out to get the diagnosis. [00:22:42] All you needed to do was go back and forth between feeling depressed and feeling better, which is kind of common. People didn't change, nor did the incidence of the condition. Only the diagnostic criteria changed. So, in effect, the diagnostic manual created an epidemic. Now, I wanted to get a broader understanding of this, so I researched what else was happening in psychiatry at the time. [00:23:08] And what I found shocked me. [00:23:13] The change to the disease criteria occurred at the exact same time that antipsychotic drugs were being rebranded as mood stabilizers, the treatment of choice for bipolar disorder. When I dug further into this, I discovered a pattern. New diagnostic criteria and even brand new mental illnesses often appear in the manual at exactly the same time that new psychiatric drugs which treat those diseases are brought to market. Coincidence? [00:23:45] I don't think so. In fact, many mental illness categories are created after their drugs are developed. [00:23:54] We've moved away from a time in which drug companies try to make a medication to fit an illness to to a time in which they invent disease profiles to suit a drug. [00:24:05] For example, in the case of depression, if you can find a drug that has effects on sleep and appetite, you can develop a depression rating scale that gives emphasis to these specific parameters. By doing so, you can create the definition of an illness to suit the profile of a particular drug. [00:24:26] Flash forward to today and a crazy amount of people suddenly seem to have bipolar disorder. [00:24:33] But more people don't have the condition. It's just easier to get the diagnosis. [00:24:39] And one more important point that needs to be said. 100% of the manual's authors have financial investments in the pharmaceutical industry. Oh, go figure. [00:24:51] In Switzerland, I had a lot of clients who had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder by their psychiatrists. [00:24:57] One of them, I'll call clara, was a 22 year old student at the University of Abzurich. [00:25:03] She told me she'd received her diagnosis and medication a few months earlier, but hated the side effects of the meds. In the next episode, I'm going to tell you how she totally transformed her severe mood swings. [00:25:18] And it wasn't through the medication. It was through consciously processing what she was experiencing instead of suppressing it. [00:25:29] See you next time. [00:25:30] Stay aware. [00:25:52] Hey, I'm Dr. Zwig. Thanks so much for watching. If you want to connect with the transformative power of your life issues, subscribe to the channel and check out the next episode in the playlist for exclusive content, join the mailing list, check the links below.

Other Episodes

Episode 56

August 03, 2022 • 00:21:35
Episode Cover

#56: How to Use Your Phone Camera to Work on a Problem

A practical exercise in which you video yourself talking about a problem, tap into a new, more objective perception of your issue, and give...

Listen

Episode 57

September 09, 2022 • 00:24:40
Episode Cover

#57: How Objective Are You About Yourself?

Being objective about yourself isn’t easy. You need a method to observe and facilitate your inner processes in a neutral, non-ideological way. Conventional psychology...

Listen

Episode 16

December 09, 2020 • 00:28:35
Episode Cover

#16: Processing Your Inner Critic Transforms Your Depression!

Conventional psychologists and psychiatrists diagnose depression by asking leading questions about things like apathy, hopelessness, loss of interest or pleasure in things, sleep problems,...

Listen